Last reviewed by Faculty of Harvard Medical School on January 24, 2013
By Harvey B. Simon, M.D.
Harvard Medical School
Most men know that exercise is good for them. But if exercise means a trip to the gym or a 5-mile run, exercise becomes a "spectator sport" for too many men. Vigorous exercise is great for guys who are so inclined, but for many others, there is a kinder, gentler way to exercise for health.
Back to top
The Aerobics Doctrine
The scientific study of exercise blossomed in the 1960's and 1970's. Researchers used a tool called the maximum oxygen uptake test, which measures the amount of oxygen sucked up by the lungs, pumped by the heart and delivered to the muscles during maximal exertion on a treadmill or stationary bicycle. Improvements in the maximum oxygen uptake also called the VO2max quickly became the gold standard for judging the benefits of exercise.
Research showed that the biggest improvements in the VO2max depend on exercise that is intense enough to raise the heart rate to 70% to 85% of its maximum heart rate for 20 to 60 minutes continuously, at least three times a week. The aerobics doctrine was born along with the no pain, no gain school of thought.
Back to top
Aerobics A Hard Sell
The aerobics doctrine gained acceptance just as Olympic champion Frank Shorter and marathoner Bill Rodgers proved that Americans could run. Running became the symbol of aerobic exercise and the marathon took over as the icon of success. Despite extraordinary individual achievements, however, the aerobics revolution did not succeed in getting our nation off its collective duff.
The aerobics doctrine inspired the few but discouraged the many. A relatively small number of lucky people discovered the benefits (and pleasures) of aerobic exercise. But by proclaiming that the only way to really benefit from exercise was through aerobic training, doctors discouraged people who found aerobic activities, such as running, too difficult. According to the "gospel of aerobics," golf was the perfect way to ruin a 4-mile walk. But we now know that's wrong.
Back to top
The Benefits of Moderation
New studies show that it's possible to attain nearly all the health benefits of exercise without high-intensity activity that leaves you drenched in sweat. That means moderate exercise, such as walking, biking, and gardening can help you get fit. Exercise intensity is less important than the overall amount of time spent exercising, and intermittent exercise is as effective as continuous activity. In fact, golf is beneficial, as long as players walk the course and play two to three times a week.
Research involving more than 320,000 people from around the world proves that regular moderate exercise can reduce risk factors, such as high cholesterol, high blood sugar, blood pressure and body fat, which we expect will improve health and reduce the risk for many chronic diseases.
Although we don't have the advantage of randomized clinical trials that evaluate the effects of exercise on cardiac events and mortality in healthy men and women, doctors have data from 48 trials of patients with proven coronary artery disease. About half of the 8,940 patients studied were randomly assigned to receive the best medical and surgical care available, while the others got the same standard of care and participated in a cardiac rehabilitation program based on moderate exercise. The exercisers came out on top. They enjoyed a 26% reduction in the risk of death from heart disease and a 20% reduction in the overall death rate. It's powerful evidence that exercise protects the heart and what's good for ailing hearts should be at least as beneficial for healthy ones!
Summary of the Research
If reducing risk factors for cardiovascular disease were the only benefit of moderate exercise, it would still be vitally important. But moderate exercise also helps:
I know what you're thinking: There must be some catch. There isn't. To get the astounding health benefits of exercise merely takes walking at a moderate pace for 30 to 40 minutes a day, with the goal of covering about 2 miles. If you need to lose weight, build up to 4 miles a day. Remember you can divide your walking into 8 to 12-minute segments throughout the day if that's more convenient. And you can substitute other activities, such as climbing stairs, gardening, biking, dancing, swimming, playing racquet sports, or yes, even golfing as long as you walk the course.
Moderate exercise is the key to exercising for health. But many people will get extra benefits by adding exercises for strength, flexibility, and balance not necessarily at a gym under the watchful eye of a trainer, but at home in just a few minutes a day. And a prudent diet is an essential part of a healthy lifestyle to prevent many of the chronic illnesses that plague modern societies. Medical science continues to make astounding advances. It has taken the collective effort of many dedicated scientists to bring us back to the wisdom of Hippocrates. Some 2,400 years ago, the Father of Medicine said, "If we could give every individual the right amount of nourishment and exercise, not too little and not too much, we would have found the safest way to health."